Distinguishing Medigap Carriers: A Comprehensive Guide

Distinguishing Medigap Carriers: A Comprehensive Guide

Most of us should enroll in Medicare as soon as we can — which is around age 65. Depending on your plan, the program can cover your health care costs, preventative services, and prescription drug coverage. 

However, Medicare doesn’t cover all healthcare expenses. 

For instance, Medicare Part A covers 80% of skilled nursing facilities, hospital care, and hospice fees. On the flip side, Medicare Part B covers 80% of necessary medical equipment and outpatient care.

For the 20% gap that Original Medicare leaves, you can buy Medigap (Medicare Supplement insurance) or Medicare Advantage Plan from a private carrier. The Medigap plan will cover costs such as:

  • Medicare Part A coinsurance and hospital cost
  • Medicare Part B coinsurance and copayment
  • Foreign travel exchange (not available in Medigap Plans A, B, K, and L)
  • Medicare Part B excess charge (only available in Medigap Plans F and G)
  • Blood (first three pints)
  • Skilled facility coinsurance (unavailable in Plans A and B)
  • Medicare Part B deductibles
  • Medicare Part A hospice care coinsurance

However, Medigap carriers vary in terms of plans they offer, premium prices, states they serve, customer services, and extra perks they offer.

To help you distinguish Medigap carriers, the Florida Medicare Expert analyzed data on the nationwide U.S. insurance companies, examined the number of Medigap plans they offer, and checked how they ranked regarding their financial health. And here are how the best 5 Medigap Carriers compare.


Standout Features

  • Offers coverage in 49 states
  • Presents ten types of Medigap plans
  • Plans can include extra benefits beyond what the federal Medicare program requires

Why We Rank Humana Medigap Policy at The Top Position

On the Fortune 500 list, Humana ranks 40. The carrier is one of the largest health insurance providers in the United States, providing Medigap coverage for all states except Virginia. Besides the wide range of Medigap plan offerings, you can get plenty of membership perks like SilverSneaker, meal delivery, and a 6% enrollment discount.

The carrier’s Medigap coverage stretches beyond what regulatory bodies demand from Medicare Supplement. For instance, you can get sharing options for dental and vision care. However, its premium prices tend to be higher than competitors, and its customers appear to file more complaints.


  • A- rating from A.M. Best in 2022
  • Provides Part D Medigap policy for prescription drugs
  • Offers dental and vision Medicare benefits
  • Live chat support


  • Customers file more complaints than competitors
  • Medigap plans are unavailable in Virginia
  • Worse than average pricing for Plan G

Enrolling in Humana online guarantees a 6% discount on your monthly premium.

Blue Cross Blue Shield

Standout Features

  • Offers Medigap coverage in all 50 states
  • Delivers ten types of Medigap policies
  • Some Medigap plans exceed regulatory requirements
  • Inexpensive hearing, vision, and dental coverage

Why Blue Cross Blue Shield Medicare Supplement Insurance Plans Ranked Second

The Medigap cover that Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) provides can vary from state to state because it’s a collection of 34 independent and locally operated companies. However, you’ll get every type of Medigap plan in at least one location across the country. 

All tts companies cover approximately 3.6 million Medigap beneficiaries nationwide.

More importantly, several Medigap plans from (BCBS) include benefits beyond what regulations demand, such as fitness membership, discount programs, and more.


  • Received an A-rating from A.M Best in 2022
  • Delivers Part D coverage for prescription drug
  • Offers Medigap plans in Washington, D.C., and Puerto Rico
  • Extensive discount program


  • Inconsistent customer experience because of different companies offering the cover
  • All types of Medigap plans aren’t available in every area

To understand what it would be like to work with Blue Cross Blue Shield, connect with a specific company that services your area.

Mutual of Omaha

Standout Features

  • Offers coverage in 49 states
  • Present only six types of Medicare supplement insurance plans
  • Plans can include extra benefits beyond federal government requirementd

Why Mutual Omaha Ranks 3rd

Mutual Omaha has been in business for over 100 years, offering U.S. adults coverage with their Medigap plan and other types of insurance. 

Unlike its competitors, you’ll find everything you need to know about plans on Mutual Omaha’s website in a clear and easy-to-understand way. As a result, you’ll have an easy enrollment.

If you prefer face-to-face enrollment, you can contact the insurance company agency in your area, get a free quote, and apply for a Medigap.


  • Received A+ rating from A.M Best in 2022
  • Provides Part D coverage (for prescription drugs)
  • Offers dental benefits reducing out-of-pocket costs
  • Presents an affordable, highly-deductible Medigap Plan G


  • You won’t find all types of Medigap plans
  • Unavailable in Massachusetts
  • Customer Support is only available during business hours only

Many customers reviews point out the quality of customer services, overall satisfaction with coverage, and fast claim fulfillment. According to the company, Mutual of Omaha pays 98% of Medicate claims within 12 hours.


Standout Features

  • Offers Medigap coverage in 48 states
  • Present six types of Medicare supplement plans
  • Plans can include extra benefits beyond regulatory requirements

Why Cigna’s Medicare Supplement Insurance Ranks 4th in Medigap Policy

Cigna has withstood the test of time in the insurance world for over 200 years. With over 1.5 million relationships with clinics, health care providers, and facilities, Cigna’s network allows it to provide services to over 180 million customers in over 30 countries. 

The carrier is known for its competitive, extra no-cost programs and reliable services. For instance, you can get free online quotes for any of Cigna’s six Medigap plans.


  • A-rating from A.M. Best in 2022
  • Provides Part D coverage ( for prescription drugs)
  • Provides extra discount for online enrollment


  • You won’t find all types of Medigap plans
  • Medigap plan still unavailable in New York and Massachusetts

Cigna Medigap plan earned a 4-star rating from the CMS (Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services) for customer satisfaction, quality preventative services, and excellent chronic condition management.

A Table Distinguishing The Top Medigap Carriers

Medigap Carrier



Extra Features
Offers the lowest cost, high-deductible Plan G

A- from A.M Best 2022
6% discount for online enrollment5% – 12% household discount and electronic payment discount

Live chat support
Well-priced Medigap carrier for Plan G

A- from A.M Best 2022
Multi-policy discountElectronic funds transfer discountAnnual payer discount

Online brain health program
Blue Cross Blue Shield
Offers all Medigap plan types

A from A.M. Best 2022
5% multi-policy discountOther wellness discounts
Affordable vision, dental, and hearing coverage
Mutual Omaha
The best Medigap carrier  with a premium discount
A+ from A.M. Best 2022Discounts on fitness, hearing, and vision planDental coverage available
Cigna Some plans of Cigna include a 24/7 health information phone line connecting you to licensed nurses
A from A.M Best 2022
20% premium discount & 5% when you apply onlineNo additional cost programs and services

How to Pick The Best Medigap Carrier for You

The suitable Medigap carrier varies from one person to another. However, to find the perfect match, you’ll need to evaluate the carrier in terms of:

  • Availability in your state
  • The number of Medigap plan types they offer and if what’s available suits you
  • Whether you’ll get Part D (prescription drug) coverage specifically
  • Whether you can get extra coverage beyond what regulatory authorities require Medigap plans to have
  • A.M best rankings in terms of financial health (which influence how reliable a carrier is when it comes to paying claims)
  • Customer feedback from ranking sites like J.D. power
  • Medicare supplement insurance cost to ensure compatibility with your budget
  • How well do the carrier plans align with your specific healthcare needs and preferences

Final Take

At Florida Medicare Expert, we’re here to help you understand how Medigap and all its moving parts and plans work to complement the Original Medicare coverage. We’ll help you decide between Medicare Advantage Plans or Medigap since you can’t have both.

Above is just a listing of Medigap carriers. We can guide you to buy a Medigap policy that suits you best. Contact us today to get the exact Medigap quote that suits you best.

Get a FREE Insurance Quote!

FHI Client Testimonials

"Evan was awesome answered all my questions and got me set up on a great plan! I can’t thank him enough. I finally have a plan that will meet my needs!"
Paula Murray Review Photo
Paula M.
Google Review
"Evan was very professional and quick to help! He was also very knowledgeable. I will definitely be working with this business in the future!!"
Gina Tocora Review Photo
Gina T.
Google Review
"Moving from New York to Florida and we’re given Evans name. Evan has been nothing short of professional and knowledgeable health insurance broker."
Susan Price Review Photo
Susan P.
Google Review

Read More Client Testimonials on Our Google My Business Page

FHI Insurance Partners

Cigna Logo
United Healthcare Logo
Aetna Logo
Humana Logo

Get a Free Insurance Quote!